
Everyone hopes to produce on opening morning, but one thing we always have to keep in mind is ensuring the animal we are shooting at is the species we actually have a tag for. In the case of Michigan’s gun season, which opened last week, a pair of hunters got “lucky” in what has turned out to be the worst sense. The two hunters involved, working separately in Montmorency and Otsego counties, each claimed to have thought they were looking at a whitetail but ended up blasting elk instead. The pair then did the admirable thing and called the DNR on themselves.
Cases of misidentification happen each and every year but in this particular case, having two unrelated incidents (and individuals) finding themselves in identical situations is relatively rare. In the first case, one hunter in Montmorency County shot a calf while the other, who was in Otsego County, killed a 12-point bull. DNR officials went on to confirm that both of the cases were indeed self-reported mistakes and that the two hunters would most certainly be on the hook for some form of restitution for the animals.
“This just reminds us to make sure that you know the game that you’re hunting and you identify it,” Gaylord DNR Lt. Jim Gorno said.
Gorno described the cases as examples of negligence that happen occasionally in Michigan’s elk range. The DNR has long warned hunters in the Pigeon River Country area—primarily Montmorency, Otsego, and surrounding counties—that young bulls and calves can be mistaken for deer, especially in low light or when animals are mixed together.

See the difference? | Michigan DNR
Elk are obviously substantially larger than white-tailed deer, standing two to four feet taller and weighing several hundred pounds more. Mature bull elk carry much larger, more sweeping headgear and typically show a lighter-colored back and hindquarters against a darker neck and head. Currently speaking, Michigan’s elk population is estimated at roughly 1,150 animals and is managed through two limited-entry hunts each year, which do not overlap with gun deer seasons.
This isn’t the first time innocent elk have hit the ground either, with similar mistakes having occurred in the same region before. In 2015, a hunter in Montmorency County shot a bull on opening day and immediately reported it, along with another similar situation in 2016 near Atlanta. Gorno said at the time that such incidents happen but are often unreported, but noted that the double occurrence on a single opening day this year is what has drawn extra attention.
At this point, officials have confirmed that the hunters are likely to face restitution of up to $1,500 for the animals and are leaving the rest up to the discretion of county prosecutors to decide whether any additional charges are warranted.

