
You won’t find his picture on the Idaho Fish and Game Commission page any longer
The Idaho Fish and Game commissioner who was charged earlier this year in connection with an illegal elk hunt has found a horseshoe up his ass reached a plea agreement.
Brody Harshbarger, the Upper Snake Region representative appointed by Gov. Brad Little, has agreed to plead guilty to two misdemeanor charges, including hunting without a valid tag and shooting from or across a public highway. In exchange for his admission of guilt, prosecutors are dropping the remaining counts from the original seven-charge case.
Those dropped charges include two counts of unlawfully taking or killing a big game animal, hunting with the aid of a motorized vehicle, failure to make a reasonable effort to retrieve a six-point bull elk, and trespassing to hunt or fish.
This particular case stems from a December 20, 2025, incident near the Spring Hollow boat ramp in Fremont County. A Citizens Against Poaching tip led officers to a six-point bull elk on private property and an antlerless bull on adjacent Bureau of Reclamation land. Court records indicated Harshbarger had already filled his elk tag the previous weekend but felt as though he had a few more shots in him before the season ended. He and another man by the name of Eric Murphy allegedly fired across Spring Hollow Road, with Harshbarger letting bullets fly from the driver’s seat of a vehicle. In what seems to be something of a thrill-kill, neither of the two men attempted to obtain permission to retrieve the six-point bull, and did not make a reasonable effort to recover it.
Under the plea agreement, it looks like Harshbarger is going to be handed a sweetheart deal that includes a $500 fine on each of the two remaining charges and the revocation of his hunting license for one year. A judge will ultimately decide how “sweet” that deal is at his sentencing hearing which is now scheduled for December 9th.
Amid the allegations, Harshbarger voluntarily postponed his commissioner duties after the charges became public back in March, but as of mid-November, Gov. Little’s office has not asked for his resignation. The governor’s spokeswoman said the office is aware of the plea and is working with the Department of Fish and Game and stakeholders. Harshbarger’s name, photo, and bio no longer appear on the official Idaho Fish and Game Commission page, while the other six commissioners remain listed. His term was not scheduled to expire until June 30.
Local hunters have continued to raise concerns about the Upper Snake Region going without active representation on the commission while the case has played out. Unfortunately, it sounds like everyone is going to have to wait until sentencing details are released to see if/when any further action will be taken with regards to the commission seat in question.

