
Ernst’s 2022 bust | Michigan DNR
While most of us continue to wonder what lifetime hunting bans actually do to deter chronic poachers, a Michigan man went ahead and answered that question for us: nothing. This story about a 38-year-old with nearly a decade’s worth of previous charges, who just so happened to already be under a lifetime hunting ban, is now facing a fresh set of charges after authorities say he killed five deer over a two-day span in late October and early November.
Justin Ernst, of Lapeer County, was arraigned in Van Buren County’s 7th District Court on eight counts stemming from incidents in Paw Paw and Lawrence townships on October 31st and November 1st. According to the Michigan Department of Natural Resources, the deer included two 9-point bucks and one 8-point, resulting in a fresh collection of charges including five counts of killing deer outside of firearm season, one count of hunting while revoked, one count of off-road vehicle trespassing, and one count of recreational trespassing. For the moment, the DNR is seeking $22,000 in reimbursement.

Current evidence against Ernst | Michigan DNR
Ernst, who seems to work in batches of illegal bucks, is no stranger to these types of cases. In 2021, officers investigating an unrelated matter (reported as a domestic violence complaint) discovered multiple trophy bucks in a barn he frequented. That led to a multi-agency investigation and, ultimately, a 2022 plea in which he admitted to illegally taking nine trophy whitetails. He was sentenced to 18 months to five years in prison, ordered to pay $25,000 in restitution, and received a permanent loss of hunting privileges in Michigan. He also had earlier deer-related charges dating back to 2018.
“We believe our department has highlighted the severity of these continued crimes by Ernst, and he is essentially robbing the public of a valued resource,” said Brandon Kieft, chief of the Michigan Department of Natural Resources Law Enforcement Division. “We hope these charges will help prevent further issues with this habitual offender.”
The latest allegations come with additional non-poaching charges requested by the Van Buren County Sheriff’s Office related to the arrest itself. Bond was initially set high, reflecting the combination of the wildlife counts and the other alleged offenses.

Some bucks from Ernst’s 2022 bust | Michigan DNR
Under Michigan law, illegally taking deer is generally a misdemeanor carrying fines of $200 to $1,000 per count and up to 90 days in jail, plus restitution that scales with the animal (higher for antlered bucks). Hunting while a license is revoked carries steeper exposure, which could include up to 180 days in jail and fines between $500 and $2,500. Because Ernst already faces a lifetime ban, further license revocation at this point would be largely symbolic. The practical levers left to the court are the stacked jail time across multiple counts, the $22,000 restitution figure, and whatever results from the additional charges tied to the arrest.
Cases like this do a great job illustrating an unfortunate but recurring reality in wildlife enforcement. Once a lifetime ban is in place, many repeat offenders simply continue without licenses (in many cases they never used one anyways), leaving fines and actual incarceration as the primary tools available to conservation officers and prosecutors. Whether this round produces a sentence substantial enough to change behavior remains to be seen, but the DNR’s public framing makes clear they view Ernst as someone who has already exhausted the system’s lighter options.

